Surprise Is Not Suspense

Together with my fellow Kritique Kritic bloggers, I had a blast this past weekend at the Cuesta Writers’ Conference. A round of applause goes to everyone who organized the event, and who (like our Laurie Woodward) volunteered their time to make sure attendees had a trouble-free experience.
The opportunity to get to know other writers was motivational (thank goodness, I’m NOT the only one who has characters who don’t do what I tell them!) and the speakers were inspiring. I’m sure we’ll all cover many points over the next few weeks; but that’s a lot of information to process, so I’ll start with one bit at a time.
During his mystery writing workshop—”From Crime to Crime”—speaker Dennis Palumbo gave a tip that hit me like a ton of bricks. As a matter of fact, when he illustrated it, the whole class shrieked. (Me the loudest, much to my embarrassment.)
I’ll share his tip in a moment; but first, here’s a video I’d like you to watch:
PLANE LANDS TOO CLOSE FOR COMFORT:
Mr. Palumbo’s tip?
Surprise is not suspense.
While writing my mystery novel, I’ve been thinking in terms of surprise. What plot twist will surprise the reader? What kind of surprise ending can I create? But just like with this video, it’s suspense, not surprise, that makes a great story.
First, you read the title: “Plane Lands Too Close for Comfort.” Already that gives you a feeling of foreboding. Oh, man, what am I going to see here?
As the video opens, you see the plane approaching. It takes for-evah. And because of the title, you flat-out know it’s going to have a close call at the landing—all that remains is to wait for it. ~~Cringe.~~ In Dennis Palumbo’s words, “Suspense is when we know it will happen, we dread it will happen.”
When the plane sweeps overhead with explosive sound and massive bulk, you gasp. After the people and red car appear, and you realize they were inches away from the plane, you exclaim aloud, “Oh, my gosh!” (Or something stronger, as a member of my family happened to do.)
That’s surprise. The noise, the explosion, the realization of something astounding. Waiting for it all to happen? That’s suspense. And as a matter of fact, it’s suspense that makes the surprise better.
Even after the plane has landed, the thrill lingers in a viewer’s mind. (Notice the flabbergasted guy at the end of the video.) The best writing is like that. Long after we’ve finished reading a work, we remember how it built anticipation, then paid off with a thrill. As with many other experiences in life, the journey is as important as the destination.
So I’m going to take Dennis Palumbo’s advice to heart. Whether I’m writing a mystery novel or a blog post, I’ll remember to…
…build suspense.


























